About Us

Our Spicy Beginnings

Spicy Pie Downtown Fargo

We got our start many moons ago, as a small pizza joint in the heart of downtown Fargo, North Dakota. Over the years, we’ve been lucky enough to expand from Fargo throughout North Dakota, adding locations in Downtown Fargo, West Fargo, South Fargo, Grand Forks, and Minot. And we’re extra excited for expansion plans throughout North Dakota, in the near future.

The plan is simple at Spicy Pie: provide you with a great tasting pizza and excellent overall experience, by using of the best and freshest pizza ingredients. We want you to have a high-quality pizza, grinder, and other menu items every time you come to see us. The pizza dough you enjoy on each pizza-pie, is hand tossed to perfection. And the tostadas, tacos, or tortilla chips you order before or during each meal are made daily in the house. We don’t scrimp, either. We use a special cheese called Saputo cheese on our pizzas. And we use an outstanding tomatoes on our pizzas as well, called Alta Cucina tomatoes. These two items alone give you a unique experience that simply cannot be replicated on the midwest prairie.

All of the food you order when at Spicy Pie is made to order. This means none of it sits around waiting for someone to buy it, like other pizza shops. You simply create the perfect combination for your pizza or grinder, and we custom make it every time. And don’t be shy. Load up your pizza with anchovies, and put whatever you like on that tostada. We won’t judge. Like we said, we give you what you want.

What is New York Style Pizza?

Spicy Pie New York Style PizzaThe pizzas you order at Spicy Pie are made like a New York style pizza. New York style pizza originated in New York City in the early 1900s. It’s best known for it’s extra large, foldable slices of pizza, with the traditional toppings like tomatoes, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese and any additional toppings that you desire. New York style pizza is typically hand tossed, light on the sauce, and comes in large sizes. Customers often fold the slices while eating them because they’re so big. At Spicy Pie, we serve you New York style pizza, that you eat by folding. But we’ll let you use a fork if you’re trying it for the very first time. You’ll only get New York style pizza in Fargo at Spicy Pie.

What is a Spicy Pie Grinder?

Grinders are like a hoagie, or sub-sandwich. They’re assembled on two pieces of bread, using our own handmade, long, soft, wide rolls. They’re best served with ingredients like ham, turkey, salami or taco. The most popular grinder guests order is called the Ultimate. The Ultimate includes all kinds of meats and also comes with toppings like shredded lettuce, cheese, and our red sauces or white grinder sauces. For those of you who are grinder aficionados, you’ll love choosing any of the meats typically used to top our pizzas. Your grinder can be served cold or can be warmed up to make it even better than it already is.


Red and White Grinder Sauce

Our signature red and white grinder sauces are not just for grinders, but for other menu items too. What makes our red grinder sauce great is the tomato-based sauce infused with savory spices and served cold. Our white grinder sauce is excellent because of the mayonnaise-based dressing that’s melded with equally savory spices and served cold. These sauces, while finding on your menu items at Spicy Pie, are also for sale. Both the red and white sauces can be purchased at any of your local Spicy Pie locations.